Premier League2026/27James Garner is our current Everton penalty taker call, with Thierno Barry next in line.
Ndiaye and Beto left on deadline day. Garner previously converted with Barry available and is the strongest observed current-squad call; Barry and Dewsbury-Hall are provisional deputies.
Checked 2 Sept 2026. Hierarchy updated 2 Sept 2026.
Sources checked
2 sources shownPremier League penalty roles can change with transfers, team selection and recent spot-kick evidence. We publish only the order supported by the current file. Source URLs remain in the internal audit file so this page keeps readers focused on the current decision.
James Garner is our current Everton penalty taker call, with Thierno Barry next in line.
Thierno Barry is second choice behind James Garner, with Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall filed third.
For live goalscorer pricing, compare the filed order with the Goalscorer Fair Odds Lab.
