Home
Premier League2026/27Everton penalty taker
Iliman Ndiaye is our current Everton penalty taker call, with James Garner next in line.
Who takes penalties for Everton?
Iliman Ndiaye is our current Everton penalty taker call, with James Garner next in line.
This page is built as a live Il Margine club file, not a one-name list. If the first-choice taker is injured, suspended, substituted or not starting, the second and third names become the useful part of the hierarchy.
Penalty order is one input in goalscorer pricing. When Premier League fixtures are live, compare the hierarchy with the Goalscorer Fair Odds Lab.
Last verified: 30 Jul 2026
Public file updated: 30 Jul 2026.
Evidence checked
4 sources reviewed- EvertonCurrent official team material confirms Ndiaye, Garner and Beto remain Everton players.
- Fantasy Football ScoutLists Ndiaye, Garner and Beto.
- Fantasy Football ScoutGarner converted an 89th-minute in-match penalty while Beto and Barry were on the pitch and Ndiaye was at AFCON. Their later shootout misses are excluded from hierarchy evidence.
- Premier LeagueNdiaye converted a regular-time penalty against Bournemouth.
Source URLs are retained in the internal review file so the public page stays focused on the hierarchy.
We update the order only when the evidence changes: penalties taken or missed, lineup context, injuries, suspensions, transfers, coaching comments, or strong league-specific signals.
Spot a hierarchy shift? Send it to us and we will tighten the file.
Everton penalty taker FAQ
Who is Everton's penalty taker?
Iliman Ndiaye is our current Everton penalty taker call, with James Garner next in line.
Who is Everton's second-choice penalty taker?
James Garner is listed as the next Everton penalty taker behind Iliman Ndiaye. Beto is the current third-choice name.
